Difficulties of Command
Posted on Thursday January 28th, 2021 @ 6:00am by Captain Jacquie Wilkerson & Lieutenant Commander Patrick Sutton
Mission:
Edge of Darkness
Location: Briefing Room 2, Deck 7, U.S.S. Saracen
Timeline: April 13, 2256 - 12:15 pm Ship board time
“As you can see Commodore Kupka, the situation we faced was constantly changing and evolving and I feel strongly that everything that could be done was done to prevent the loss of the McAnerin.” Jacquie leaned forward and clasped her hands on the table as looked directly at Commodore Kupka on the monitor.
“Let me start by thanking you for your reports on this matter.” Kupka paused for a moment as if was trying to figure out what to say next. “Commander Malviya, as senior surviving officer of the McAnerin let me ask you, do you feel that the initial visit to the surface of Garanth IV was warranted or necessary? Would it not have been more prudent to notate any findings and wait for the Federation Science Council or UESPA to send out a dedicated team to investigate what you discovered on the planet surface?”
Malviya adjusted himself uncomfortably in his seat as Kupka spoke. He gulped slightly as he was about to answer the Commodore’s Question. “Sir, at the time I felt the decision to investigate was both necessary and warranted as we had been assigned by UESPA to follow-up probe readings from nearly a century ago.” Malviya paused as he raised his index finger and pointed for effect. “Probe readings that told us that Garanth IV was as devoid of life as the moon.”
“No one is questioning the probe telemetry Commander, but would you have made the call to send the first landing party to the planet, which seems to be what started us down this unfortunate path.” Kupka asked again failing to mask the slight annoyance in his voice.
“I would have made the same call that Captain Watters made, and I believe any officer in this room would have done the same thing if they were in the Captain’s shoes.” Defiance filled Malviya’s voice as he spoke.
“With all due respect Commodore, I wasn’t on the Bridge of the McAnerin whent he initial discovery was made, but having spent some time with Captain Watters on board that starship.” Sutton interjected before Kupka had a chance to respond. “I do have to question why we are looking into the Captain’s decision or competency as a Commanding Officer when Captain Watters’ actions more than likely saved my life, and countless others when he fired the Reaction Control Thrusters.” Sutton concluded as he looked at Malviya and nodded.
“Why is it when someone uses the phrase ‘With all due Respect’ the last thing that comes out of their god-damned mouths is respect.” Kupka grumbled.
“I am really not sure Commodore, but I second my First Officer’s assessment of Captain Watters as being correct,” Jacquie quickly interjected. “Up to my last conversation with him, the only concern on Captain Watters’ mind was the safety of his ship, and the welfare of those on the planet. Which is why I authorized Lieutenant Ellis to send a landing party from this ship to ascertain their wellbeing.”
“That was a rhetorical question Captain, but while you mention where is Lieutenant Ellis, and why is she not at this meeting?” Jacquie could sense by the tone of the Commodore’s voice that Kupka’s annoyance and frustration was growing.
“Sir, she is probably on the Bridge aiding with the recovery of the McAnerin survivors, as I didn’t feel that it was necessary to have her to attend this briefing. Especially when Commander Malviya was already going to be here to testify to the events on the planet.”
“I am still unclear Commander as to what you and your landing party discovered on the planet surface.” Kupka leaned back in his chair and interlocked his fingers. “Was there a connection to Ancient Earth or not? You have been frustratingly vague on the subject.”
“That was not my intention Commodore, however part of the conditions of myself and Cadet Moorhead being released was that we promised not to bring undue attention to the planet or its inhabitants.” Malviya calmly asserted. “Which is why I must ask that the Federation and UESPA list this planet as off limits until such time that the inhabitants of Garanth IV want to have contact with us.”
“As I said Commander, I will pass that request up the chain of command.” Kupka answered. “However that may not be possible as Garanth IV is one of only a handful of Class-M Planets near the Klingon Neutral Zone that Federation and Starfleet could use as Early Warning outposts should the Klingons decided to attack.”
Jacquie looked over at Sutton, who she spotted rolling his eyes at the Commodore’s comments. She leaned back in her own chair as she began to speak. “Back to the issue that we were discussing, I do not belief for a moment that Captain Watters is either to blame for the loss of the McAnerin or thought that the starship would be hazarded in any way.”
Kupka let out a small sigh as he studied Jacquie as if trying to size her up. “I will make sure your comments are added to the official transcript of this meeting.” Kupka paused and leaned forward. “But in all honesty Captain, I doubt your comments will mean more than a bucket of warm spit, a starship was lost with nearly a third of her crew, someone is going to be responsible for that.”
“So blame the one guy that can’t defend himself, I see how it is!” Malviya exclaimed without thinking.
“Commander! That is enough.” Both Jacquie and Haversford who had remained quiet up to this point shouted at Malviya.
Malviya put up his hand in surrender as he lowered his head. “I’m sorry Commodore, I don’t feel it is right to railroad a dedicated officer like Captain Watters when he can do nothing to defend himself.”
“I can assure you son that we are not looking to railroad anyone,” Kupka leaned forward in his chair. “I am just looking for a true accounting of all the facts, so it can be determined if a further inquiry into this matter is warranted. I was merely letting all of you know that in this case someone may have to take the blame, especially as the McAnerin was not lost to enemy action.”
“Understood Admiral.” Haversford stated before anyone else could as he looked over at Malviya who still had his head down. “But that leaves us with one thing outstanding.”
Haversford raised an eyebrow as he leaned back in his chair slightly. “And what would that be Captain Haversford?”
“The fate of the hulk of the McAnerin, My ship could tow her back to Starbase 11 for salvage and recovery.” Haversford offered as he looked around the briefing room.
“That would leave the area open for Elasi pirate operations for too long,” Kupka shook his head no as he answered almost without thought.
“What about the Saracen?” Jacquie asked. “We are due to put in at Starbase 11, to deionize our systems and to debrief with Sector Command, we could tow the hulk back.”
Kupka again shook his head no. “I am sorry Captain this mission has delayed you enough already,” He paused for a moment. “And towing the hulk back to Starbase 11 would limit your speed, it could prompt a hostile act from either the Elasi or Klingons.”
Jacquie pursed her lips in frustration as she studied the Commodore’s imagine on the screen. “Sir with all due respect, we can not just leave the McAnerin to drift aimlessly out here. She could become a hazardous to navigation, or devastating if she were to fall into planetary orbit.”
Kupka finally nodded. “Fortunately the Commander in Chief of Starfleet and President agree with you, though not for the reasons you are giving.” Kupka raised his hands to stop anyone from speaking. “The Garanth System is far too close Klingon Space for us to leave the McAnerin just drifting out there, not to mention, should the Elasi or Nausicaans get access to her, there is not telling how Starfleet or the Federation could be compromised. So with that in mind I have been tasked with giving you, your next orders.” Kupka reached down and picked up a Padd and began to read.
“To Captain Jacquie Wilkerson, Commanding Officer U.S.S. Saracen from Fleet Admiral Norah Brown, Commander in Chief Starfleet Command.” Kupka took a breath for a second before continuing. “On this date, April 13, 2256 you are hereby ordered to destroy the wreck of the starship McAnerin, ensuring that nothing can be salvaged and used to compromise the security of either Starfleet or the United Federation of Planets. Signed Fleet Admiral Brown, April 13, 2256, 0845 Earth Standard time.” Kupka handed the orders to his aide. “These orders will be forwarded to you immediately, you are expected to finish the rescue efforts, recover any of the crew of the McAnerin that are still alive and able to be saved. Once that is complete you will carry out the orders for the final disposition of the starship.”
Jacquie lowered her head for a moment and then raised it to look at Kupka. “Yes sir, was there anything else required?” She simply asked not bothering to hide the exhaustion in her voice.
“Not at this time Captain, I will forward your debrief to the Fleet Admiral and President, you will be notified if you or anyone in that room is needed for an Article 32 hearing.” Kupka stated. “Oh and Captain Haversford, you and the Tecumseh are expected to be back on your patrol station within the next 4 hours. Kupka out.” He said as he closed the communications channel.
“Well that was fun.” Sutton leaned back in his chair and rubbed his eyes. “What are your orders Captain?”
Jacquie stood up and stretched before smoothing the gold skirt of her uniform. “We follow our orders, as distasteful as they are, they are lawful and we will abide by them.” She put her hands on hips and looked at her First Officer. “I don’t like firing on the wreckage of our own ships either, but the Commodore has a point, for all we know the McAnerin’s Main Computer Core is still intact, if that can be decoded, an enemy could have access to every prefix code in the fleet, we can’t let that happen.”
Sutton nodded. “Yes ma’am, sorry it has been a long few days.”
Jacquie smiled slightly and raised her hand. “No need to apologize Commander.” She turned to face Haversford. “Captain, you may as well offload your remain survivors to us and report back to your patrol. The Saracen and McAnerin crews thank you for your efforts here.” She said extending her hand.
Haversford nodded. “I will begin the process now, but when you are back at Starbase 11, save a spot at Amelia’s first round is on me, for Captain Watters.” He pointed as he walked out of the Briefing Room.
“If you don’t mind Captain, I will see to my crew, but when you give the order to fire on the McAnerin I just request your permission to be on the Bridge to observe, I served on her for a long time.”
Jacquie nodded. “Carry on Commander, I wouldn’t have it any other way, I will let you know when the time comes.”
“Thank you Captain, Lieutenant Ruch, let us see how we can help the survivors.” Malviya said with a sadness that was hard to hide as he and Ruch also walked out of the briefing room.
Jacquie turned to Sutton as she moved and sat down opposite him. “Shouldn’t you be in Sickbay by the way?”
“I felt it was more important to be here, then to be loafing around in Sickbay.” Sutton stated as he winced a little.
“Meaning you checked out against doctors advice.” Jacquie shook her head and smiled. “Alright get back to Sickbay, get cleared by Stam, and get changed into your dress uniform before reporting to the Bridge.” She instructed as a small smile started to emerge on her face. “If we are going to have to destroy the McAnerin we are going to send her off with full honours.” She paused for a moment.
Sutton just nodded as he stood up and moved towards the door. “Yes ma’am.” was all he said as he exited the room leaving Jacquie alone in the room with her thoughts.


